Cover of The Return of Sherlock Holmes by Arthur Conan Doyle
Read with discussion

The Return of Sherlock Holmes

by Arthur Conan Doyle · · 1903

Following his unexpected reappearance after years of presumed death, brilliant detective Sherlock Holmes resumes his partnership with Dr. John Watson in Victorian London. Together they investigate a wide array of complex crimes, ranging from cryptic ciphers and high-stakes blackmail to mysterious homicides. As Holmes relies on keen observation and logical deduction to solve each puzzle, the stories frequently examine the boundaries between formal legal standards and personal moral justice.

Age range
Ages 12–99
Category
High School Reads
ISBN
60Christian
worldview score

Content ratings

0 means absent, 5 means heavy and central.

Magic0/5
Violence2/5
Language1/5
Romance1/5
Sexual Content0/5
Scary Content2/5
LGBTQ Content0/5
Bad Behavior / Disrespect1/5

Parent notes

This classic collection of detective stories highlights the power of observation, logical reasoning, and faithful friendship. While Holmes consistently defends the innocent and opposes wickedness, parents may wish to discuss moments where he takes the law into his own hands, deciding when human mercy or unofficial judgment supersedes civil prosecution. The collection includes references to murder and violent crime scenes that are characteristic of the genre but described with Victorian restraint.

Find the full book

We only publish reviews, never book text. These independent catalogs can help you borrow or buy a copy.

Faith Reads is independent and not affiliated with any author, publisher, retailer, or the services linked above.

Discussion questions

  1. 1How does Arthur Conan Doyle invite readers to admire Sherlock Holmes's reliance on cold logic, and where might the stories suggest that human sympathy is equally vital?
  2. 2In 'The Adventure of the Dancing Men,' what tragic price did Hilton Cubitt pay for keeping his wife's past secrets hidden from the authorities?
  3. 3Which action of Dr. Watson in 'The Adventure of the Empty House' best demonstrates his unwavering loyalty when faced with the sudden, shocking return of his friend?
  4. 4Did Holmes make the right ethical decision by freeing Captain Crocker at the end of 'The Adventure of the Abbey Grange,' or should he have turned him over to official law enforcement?

Community reviews

Written by parents and caregivers, not by Faith Reads. Reviews reflect their authors' own families and traditions.

No parent reviews yet — be the first to share how this book landed in your home.

Sign in to add your own review of this book.